Butterscotch?

Black currant could be very nice.

I would love a Marshmellow flavored. It could go with Peanut butter. Then if you make a Grape Jelly we could have a Peanut Butter, Jelly, and Fluff Snuff!!!!!!

As a great fan of Earl Grey Tea I dream of a snuff with a distinctive bergamot flavour.

I also would like a snuff with Neroli Oil (like F&T Seville).

I'll second that! Best Dark is a wonderful snuff. Definitely got the right flavours.

I would like a real Latakia scent. Maybe with some oriental too, so it smells like Nightcap or something like that.
I would also be interested in a high strength, natural flavor.

Sprangalang et al,
I like the oriental idea. I had been thinking of a jewel copy, however Macalpe helped me track down a Moroccan snuff called ‘Nefha’ which I love and feel is very close to ‘SJ’. It conj ours up images of the suk (a spice market) at Marrakesh and this is tempting me to go a little more spicy than 'SJ'.
I also like quite like the bitter (beer) idea. I have to say sorry but I hate the mushroom idea, too many possibly unpleasant odors.
So many flavours so little time.
Roderick

Hehehe... mushroom snuff was partly a joke :)

Troutstroker's Root Beer / Salsaparilla idea is also quite nice. Though same as with Apple, I would fear the taste wouldn't be intense enough and rapidly fading.

How about these?

Rosemary / Basil (for italian food lovers)
Ginger / Gingerbread (this one could be delicious)
Cinnamon (though I don't know how well you could make this using only natural flavoring)
Cardamom
Piña Colada or just Coconut - I don't think I've ever seen one like this

I think you might be onto something with the pina colada or cocunut. That sounds very unique and delicious.

Quote ... mushroom snuff would be a first. I know there is a mushroom pipe tobacco

A mushroom pipe tobacco ? hmm why do I find this intersting, Tell me more georgie boy tell me more.;

Above is my shamless quote stealing from Clockwork Orange

I haven't tried the pipe tobacco called Shortcut to Mushrooms made by Just for Him, but the good reviews it received on Tobaccoreviews.com made it out to be very interesting.

If I'm not mistaken, Sam Gawith already makes a Coconut snuff. I havn't tried it yet, but I have defianatley read about it in the past.

That being said, I'd still try a Toque made Coconut flavor, since I have stated a few times before, Toque has won me over with thier strong natural scented flavorings, as compared to others....

I don't see any mention of coconut on the Sam Gawith website.

I like smarost's suggestions, cocunut and ginger sound like great ideas to me and freshly chopped basil is one of my favourite smells ever. It might be a bit odd as a snuff but who would have thought peanut butter would work so well.

Also, I was just eating passion fruit flavoured tic tacs......

Sam Gawith Coconut was discussed briefly on snuffboxthenasalclub in August of 2005, here is the link
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/snuffboxthenasalsnuffclub/message/19013

and got about 76 results discussing S.G> coconut after doing a search on that site for coconut, the results of which can be found by clicking this link
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/snuffboxthenasalsnuffclub/msearch?date=any&DM=------------&DD=----&DY=----&DM2=------------&DD2=----&DY2=----&AM=contains&AT=&SM=contains&ST=&MM=contains&MT=coconut&charset=utf-8


I'm sure I saw it available about a year ago, but I can't remember where. If I had to guess though, I believe it was available through Bespoke tobacco when he sold other brands as well as his own.

Anyways, it seems it is now not made or available so I'm sure it would make an interesting flavor for Toque which always seems to make an incredible snuff flavoring....

I'm a fan of citrus snuff so I'd back the suggestions for a Lemon or Pink Grapefruit flavour.

On the same theme, how about a St Clements - Bitter Orange and Lemon ? That would save me the pain of having to mix Seville and Lemon Grove together :o)

I also liked the Amaretto suggestion. Another booze flavour I reckon would work well would be Drambuie - Whisky and Honey. Or you could go the whole hog and go for Toddy flavour, with Whisky, Honey and Lemon. I would definitely shovel that up my nose.